FINALLY i get to answer this!
1)
yes, my favorite character is indeed entrapta. she’s incredibly relatable and complex and autistic and wonderful. i’m convinced that she was actually written by an autistic person, because holy shit, i’m so impressed.
i can understand why people would be annoyed by the autistic character being “amoral”, but i think that’s a fundamental misunderstanding of her character and her motives. catra needed to convince her that she’d been left behind before luring her in with tech for a reason.
yes, she’s doing very bad things right now without thinking of the consequences, but i’m certain that as soon as she realizes that the rebel princesses thought she’d died, she’ll come right back to them. like, fuck, can you imagine her reaction to the memorial garden that perfuma created in her honor? if we thought her reaction to being abandoned was sad enough…
i also really love catra, for her intense complexity, and scorpia, because i want her to be my girlfriend, and seahawk, because he’s fabulous, and bow, because he’s a sweetheart and the heart of the team (and i’m weak for boys who are the heart of the team, as you know), and–well, i could go on.
i can’t think of a character that i dislike honestly. shadow weaver was fascinating and a creepily accurate portrayal of an abusive parent. hordak was smart in a way that i could respect even though he’s, y’know, evil.
2)
my favorite parts are the complexity of the characters. i’d like to see them interact more together, but i feel like those complaints are kind of…premature? they only just decided to commit to the princess alliance in the very last episode, y’know? so i can understand why people might be frustrated that we barely saw the princesses working together aside from basically two episodes, but i think we have many wonderful interactions to look forward to!
i also really liked that the characters’ motives made sense. it’s hard to contrive a situation in which the hero’s bff actually aligns with the Bad Guys even though she doesn’t actually believe in what they do, but this show did it perfectly. it’s also hard to contrive a situation in which the autistic character aligns with the Bad Guys without being Problematic, but this show did that too. everything felt thoughtful.
my least favorite parts were some of the earlier episodes’ plots. like, perfuma’s episode’s “moral” was literally copy-pasted from the original she-ra, and not in a good way. same with entrapta’s episode’s “moral” about not relying on your powers. they felt so simplistic compared to the rest of the series.
the animation wasn’t great. i loved the colors, but, yeah, a lot of frames could use work. i’m guessing s2 will have a bigger budget though.
i can’t say that anything really disappointed me. there was that review that completely misunderstood the joke about bow not realizing what netossa and spinnerella actually do, claiming that it was Bad Rep because of that, and i’m…amazed at how off the mark it was. like, wow. it’s literally just, “bow doesn’t realize that their names are literal”, not “lesbians are stupid.”
i hope that catra gets an amazing redemption arc. i hope that we get a major explicit endgame wlw romance–but even if we don’t, i’ll know that noelle tried her best to make it happen, and i’ll be happy with that too. i hope that scorpia marries me someday.
some theories… she-ra is an avatar-like state, light hope intentionally showed those memories to tear catra and adora apart, entrapta is going to use that tech she recovered earlier to corrupt she-ra again… i think all my theories are the common ones, haha.
3)
lemme guess–that it’s toxic and abusive? idk what people expected. this is friends-to-enemies-to-lovers territory. catra is going to be Problematic and hurt adora until she redeems herself. we already saw her instinctively protect adora multiple times in the first 10.5 episodes, so like, jeez, give her a chance to go through her development.
i think this fandom is going to have a huge problem with gray morality. i’ve already gotten one idiot basically accusing me of condoning gen/ocide…all because i wrote a catra meta. god forbid i examine the complexity of the villains in this show, right? jeez, it’s not like i’m saying catra Did Nothing Wrong, which can’t be said for a lot of people stanning male Problematic Faves, so, hm.